check out Days!

Field Study

An Unedited view of design and thought process:

work, experimental and otherwise by Keenan Cummings

Case Study: What I Want Out of Facebook


Note: This experiment is in no way affiliated with Facebook, Apple, Wes Anderson, or the Tenenbaum Family. 

Another Note: This experiment is not about user interface, or touch gestures, or mobile apps. It’s about an experience and a product. It’s about relationships to people. The interactions that I’ve visualized below are far from final. I was mostly playing with how an interface could make me feel about the people it represented.

I’m a failure when it comes to Facebook. My friend count is below average. No one ‘likes’ my stuff. And I never quite finished filling out that section of my bio where I list all the bands I like and movies I’ve seen.

Or maybe Facebook has failed me. It’s not because the ads they serve up are irrelevant — sometimes they get close. They’ve done a great job reminding me of birthdays. And I’ve never questioned where to put squishy pictures of my cute baby. I know how to use Facebook, but I don’t use it much. And when nearly everyone in my home country under 50 is on this thing, I have to ask what I am missing.

There with Facebook there is an implicit promise that I feel has yet to be fulfilled: it is the promise that playing around with this awkwardly named website (yes, I know the history of the name, but just think about it — Face? Book?) will make your relationships with the people you care most about somehow better, deeper, richer, and more fulfilling. 

I know Facebook has grander ambitions. It wants to be the clearing house of the internet, the home page, the portal, the town square, the identity infrastructure for the planet, all Facebook all the time. But something about the content and interactions on Facebook screams at this fundamental core: connect with the people you care about. And yet there is so much that pulls me away from and prevents me doing just that.

I guess what I want out of Facebook is clarity. I want that promise of better relationships front and center, and I want the activities and interactions to clearly that goal. 

And I know this sounds like a humble idea for the Facebook’s world-conquering ambitions. But a tool that promises and delivers on better relationships is probably one of the most desired and universal value propositions out there (next to Foodbook, Shelterbook, and PhysicalSafetyBook).

Introducing Knitt

So I started playing around with something I am calling Knitt. Knitt is not a reduction of the entire Facebook platform. It is one simple tool that could live alongside many others. Knitt works like a to do list of kindness, a reminder to be mindful. It’s job is to learn who you are closest to and help you stay close or get closer. 


Knitt could even be super smart. Imagine you have been out of touch with a friend for a long time. One day, that friend comes to town and calls you up. You hang out, and suddenly, you’re good friends again. Knitt picks up on that increase in interactions, and instead of a bi-annual reminder to send a shout-out to that friend, Knitt increases the frequency of interactions for that rekindled relationship. 


Knitt would work both ways, helping you forgo frequent interaction with more distant acquaintances without forgetting them, and also helping you interact more often with the people that matter most. Knitt wants you to spend less time with Knitt and more time communicating and being with your own kind and kin.


What excites me about Facebook, and about ideas like Knitt that could build on top of it, is that the connections are there, the relationships largely defined. There is a ton of potential to make peoples’ lives better, and when Facebook can deliver on that promise, I’ll be glad I signed up. 

  1. obsequious-to-me reblogged this from keenancummings
  2. unreachabletruths reblogged this from keenancummings
  3. fieldstudyfolio reblogged this from keenancummings and added:
    Knitt is a concept and case study I put together to explore my thoughts on social networks and what is lacking at the...
  4. priyamaya reblogged this from keenancummings and added:
    Enjoyed this read by keenan cummings, taking the core value proposition of facebook and envisioning what it could be…
  5. jhilmd reblogged this from keenancummings
  6. oldfashionedrosie reblogged this from keenancummings and added:
    Interesting App
  7. hypermoderntimes reblogged this from keenancummings and added:
    This is a nice example of how technology can be used in a more human way… It shows that offline interactions indeed can...
  8. zakkforchilli reblogged this from keenancummings
  9. uneamourette reblogged this from keenancummings
  10. flankedbymagpies reblogged this from keenancummings
  11. shufflingalldayeveryday reblogged this from keenancummings and added:
    i like this idea … hope it gets developed :)
  12. camellialieu reblogged this from keenancummings
blog comments powered by Disqus